Sunday, January 28, 2007

Fort Wayne's Toll Road-650 Miles of Downtown Property


No wonder our Mayor Dick was rewarded with a raise. The Journal Gazette reports about Harrison Square and I blogged about early here. The Mayor calls it a catalyst, I call it a "My Man Mitch Pitch." Governor Mitch Daniels catalyst for the revitalization of Indiana was the toll road, and Mayor Graham Richard catalyst for revitalizing downtown Fort Wayne is a stadium. According to the Journal-Gazette,
We had a plan to develop a catalyst, and all of a sudden the Wizards get bought, not just by a baseball owner but by a developer used to taking risks specifically in downtown areas,” Richard said. “They said, ‘Here’s an opportunity to invest not just in a ball team, but in a dynamic rebirth of a downtown.’


Daniels rented or sold the toll road to a private company to raise money, Richard is offering property tax money which can be allocated to special taxing district. The special taxing district will use the increase in taxes from the increase in property values during a reassessment to pay for projects. This property tax increase is called TIF for short.

TIF is the diverting of revenue from the payment of property tax funds after a property value increases. If there is a the property increase more than likely so will the property tax increase. The City will keep the old amount for budget purpose and keep the difference from the increase in property tax to place into a general funds to be spent in the special district only.

But I thought the property tax was for schools, housing, you say. Yeah, but the legislators established authority to set up a commission to be responsible for directing any redevelopment commission to designate any area as a blighted area that can be developed through the ordinary operations of private enterprise including non-blighted areas for economic development. Where were you when Belmont was fighting this thing? Or the scheme of ripping off the owners' value in the Southtown Property to be used later by the public-private sector of Fort Wayne that went all the way to the Indiana Supreme Court?

Is this not the same as the families who lived in the Harrison Square area. TIF is supposed to be for the temporary allocation of redevelopment or economic district of the citizens property taxes to be used for a variety of purposes to improve the areas.

Municipal bonds are then issued to finance the public improvements. Bonds payable from TIF may be used to finance the cost of redevelopment and the construction of public improvement in the redevelopment area or for projects that directly serve or benefit that area. Once the bonds have been paid off, the taxes collected from the allocated area are distributed to the remaining taxing districts, such as schools.

TIF districts are to encourage developers to invest in dying business areas or in land banked industrial sites. Some requirements are for developers to diversify development beyond retail, connect to downtown with transportation, help existing business grow and expand, and foster economic development by assisting entrepreneurs in the area with start up and strengthen the economic base in the area.

Harrison square is sold as the public benefit and all the improvement as the catalyst attempting to duplicate Atlanta's popular Georgia Aquarium, billed as the largest as well as a museum dedicated to a soft drink company, according to the article.
Within four years, the $2 billion Allen Plaza is planned to have five other buildings in adjacent blocks that would house offices, apartments, condos, retail outlets and another hotel, all built by Barry or in partnership with Atlanta apartment landlord Post Properties.

Helping spark this revival, across from the park, is the year-old, hugely popular Georgia Aquarium, billed as the world’s largest,
and the new World of Coca-Cola, a museum under construction dedicated to the soft drink.


One City Council member, Tom Smith does not oppose the stadium being built downtown, but questions the private developers mere $5 million contribution. But Smith does not go deep enough, the public-private dollars are more like, the property owners would pay with their property taxes, $82 millions and the private owners $43 millions for the entire project.

There is nothing complicated about understanding TIF dollars. The question is where does TIF dollars come from? Answer, TIF comes from property tax after a reassessment. If you were paying $90 in property tax dollars on your property in 2001 and your property taxes increases to $270 in 2003 there is a difference. Well, the City will freeze their portion at $90 and put the remaining $180 into a general fund. The $180 is marked off as TIF to be spent just in that special district. But as the Journal-Gazette points out the success of Apple Glen and Jefferson Point as TIF and used the money from those special district to give some downtown project some of the money. But that is not how it works. This is not too much different from when the county borrowed from Hersey company and gave to General Motors abatement issues.

Wait you need to know some of these TIF special districts? Let's see:

Jefferson Pointe area, Midtown Crossing, Baer Field Economic Development Area(EDA), Centennial Park, Jefferson/Illinois EDA, Maysville Stellhorn Road EDA, Summit Industrial Park. And lets not forget the Bluffton Road area that includes General Motors, Fort Wayne Assembly. Do you understand why downtown looks like a desolate valley?

Why siphon away parts of property taxes and place into a general funds because your tax dollars can helps improve selected area instead of amenities that makes for a better quality life for all of Fort Wayne citizens. The money would pay for schools, library, housing in our city. But, tax payers don't want to subsides the lives of the poor while they giving handouts to the rich in the amount of $83 million. So, the millions of dollar that are collected in the General Motors area benefits that area not the whole city. Jefferson Pointe taxes benefit that area only not the whole city. But we offer these businesses abatements and other stuff. So what is the city doing with your property tax dollars if not paying to improve schools, giving it to developers to encourage them to take a risk in big ticket items in our city. So why is the City saying it's not increasing property taxes to build the stadium. Because it sounds good.

Now imagine this community of dreamers if you didn't have a special project where would the money go that's in the general funds? It would go toward the schools that the city is telling you that will cost billions of dollars to fix up? What do you think developers should invest in first, building for educating people rather than buildings for recreation?

Are you still with me? The City is saying it will have to raise taxes to fix schools, but.......(you need a moment to digest this)....the tax dollars from the new increase will still go into the general funds and the schools will get some of the property tax increase. That's right the new increases will benefit the special projects and not much to the schools. You elected these folks, while your children suffer. And why the Mayor is enjoying his new $130,000 salary. It's your money

11 comments:

  1. Anonymous1/29/2007

    "The City is saying it will have to raise taxes to fix schools, but.......(you need a moment to digest this)....the tax dollars from the new increase will still go into the general funds and the schools will get some of the property tax increase. "

    That is incorrect. The CITY is NOT fixing the schools. The FWCS system is fixing the schools. They are separate issues.

    The TIF funds for Harrison Square ONLY come from the buildings that sit IN Harrison Square. It will not affect property taxes for anyone else in the city.

    ReplyDelete
  2. To pseudo Kevin Knuth (because the real Knuth would know how tax dollars are distributed:

    "That is incorrect. The CITY is NOT fixing the schools. The FWCS system is fixing the schools. They are separate issues."

    Property taxes are collected from the property owners that are placed in the City and County Budget.

    Taxes collected pay for special projects, Harrison SQ and Libraries, and schools.

    So my question to you where is the money coming from to "fix" the schools? You are so right the city(property taxpayers) is fixing the schools. Next!!!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This a break down of the tax rate for determining your property tax, depending on where you live, for 2003 payable 2004.
    http://www.cityoffortwayne.org/images/stories/finance/controller/files/2003pay2004.pdf

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous1/30/2007

    this is for you, credo

    ReplyDelete
  5. anonymous:

    What happened you could not handled the truth. That you thought you were brilliant and all that, but the city stuck it hands into your pocket and took your money to subside big business.

    You'll be alright.

    Oh, and if you could just point out the lies I will admit my errors.

    Thanks for reading and your post.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Anonymous:

    Yes I read it and did you read my post on the newspaper today.

    "sophisticated financing package for the downtown revitalization effort" code words for we don't understand it and you the reader definitely won't understand it.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Anonymous1/30/2007

    "sophisticated financing package for the downtown revitalization effort"
    code words for the city trying to do everything in their effort to create a project that attracts hundreds of thousands of people to downtown, without costs coming from your property taxes. If you want to get technical and try to scare people by stating that property taxes are being used, at least explain that the only property tax being used is the tax generated by Harrison Square development. Without this development being constructed there would be nothing but weeds and parking lot. The development is in effect paying for itself.
    FWCS money is kept separate from downtown revitalization funds. That is the reason these particular districts have been created. The money generated from the area stays in the area. Property tax money generated from other areas are used for other areas, such as FWCS.

    ReplyDelete
  8. code words for the city trying to do everything in their effort to create a project that attracts hundreds of thousands of people to downtown, without costs coming from your property taxes.

    at least explain that the only property tax being used is the tax generated by Harrison Square development.


    Is there a stadium standing now in downtown? No. Is there a TIF district downtown, now. Yes.

    So where is the the tax dollars coming from at this point and time for the TIF? Answer, the property tax owners living in the area now. When was downtown declared a
    TIF?

    "The development is in effect paying for itself." Keeping saying it enough. You don't scare people by telling them the truth, you provide information to the people in order for they to make good informed decisions about who they place in leadership positions.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous1/30/2007

    I don't believe there are any funds being used from the current TIF area towards the construction costs of a baseball park. I think if this were actually the case, we would have all read about it in a huge front page story in the local paper.

    This is why city council will be voting on the use of bonds. Bonds that will then be paid off from the property tax that the TIF creates in the future. This area would not only include a ballpark, but the hotel, parking garage, and retail stores as well. Not from your property taxes, not from mine, and not from current downtown residents.

    By the way, there are about a dozen TIF areas around Fort Wayne.
    http://www.cityoffortwayne.org/images/stories/community_development/special_projects_gis/files/urban_renewal_econimic_development_areas_printable.pdf

    I agree that providing information in order for people to make a decision is the best option. After reading the baseballPlus report, the downtown blueprint report, and every article published on Harrison Square since, I think it all makes sense and provides a great opportunity for Fort Wayne.

    ReplyDelete
  10. "By the way, there are about a dozen TIF areas around Fort Wayne. "

    In one of my posting, I listed some of the actual TIF areas by name. I have a long list of the actual properties but too long to list here. But one you could start with is the Civil Center or DID commercial property owners.


    "This area would not only include a ballpark, but the hotel, parking garage, and retail stores as well. Not from your property taxes, not from mine, and not from current downtown residents."

    First we know this project is being sold to the public at this time, so no there is nothing being spent on the property. But the TIF already exist. More specifically, the land for the hotel is a TIF district.

    And just like the TIF district for Jefferson pointe that was expanded, so will the TIF district that surrround the area for the hotel will be expanded to support the stadium.

    The current funds of the hotel areas is being used to pay off the bond of the Grand Wayne Center.

    From enrollment in a state and local taxation class, it makes sense to take care of your citizens first.

    ReplyDelete